Valet · Buying Used · Pinned by mod

paid 62,400 for a 2021 S580 4MATIC off rubiautosales.com

everett_naperville
11 replies
9,742 views
Oct 14, 2025
rubiautosales.com mercedes s580 4matic w223 airmatic pre purchase inspection bought sight unseen
Showing 12 posts · Page 1 of 1

numbers first, because that is what i wanted out of these threads back when i was the one reading them. 62,400 all in with the buyer fee for a 2021 S580 4MATIC with 19,100 miles on it. the two mercedes stores near me in the west suburbs were asking 79 to 84 for the same year and mileage, and neither of their cars had the rear executive seats or the burmester 4d.

background so you know where i am coming from. i am 46, i sell industrial fasteners, and i have wanted one of these since i was nine years old riding in the back of my uncles W140 on the way to a cubs game. i drove a paid off 2015 E350 for six years and saved instead of leasing. new was never happening. a loaded W223 stickers north of 135 and i am not the guy who eats the first four years of that number.

i found the car on rubiautosales.com. one owner, lived its whole life in a state that does not salt roads, 19k miles, the rear executive seat package, and the full service history right there in the listing photos.

what actually got my attention was that they listed the flaws before i asked about any of them. curb rash on the right front 20 inch wheel, the trunk handle camera lens fogged over, one open software recall on the 48 volt system, and the front tires were the originals down around 4/32. that is not how a car gets written up by somebody trying to move it fast.

i was not wiring sixty grand off a phone call, so i paid an independent mercedes specialist to go put it on a lift. star diagnostic scan, every AIRMATIC strut checked and then the car left sitting overnight to see if a corner settled, rear differential looked at, and the sunroof drains blown out. 385 dollars. he found a plugged front drain, brake fluid two years overdue, and one stored code off the 48 volt system that he said comes from a battery disconnect. the struts all held ride height overnight. that was the whole report.

bought it. Rubi Auto Sales handled the paperwork, the title came to illinois clean and the odometer statement matched, and i had it brought up on an enclosed carrier for 1,150 because i was not flying out to drive a car i had never sat in through november weather.

anybody else in here running a flagship they bought off an online auction? i will report back after the first winter either way.

i run an independent mercedes shop outside atlanta and i have been doing nothing but these cars since the W211 was current, so let me tell you what a 2021 S580 actually is. at 19,100 miles it is a baby. the M176 in it is a known quantity, it is the same basic V8 family that has been in these cars for years and the ones that grenade are the ones that went 20,000 miles on an oil change because the service indicator said it was fine.

here is the money list on a W223 once the factory warranty is gone, and you should read it before you fall in love. the 48 volt integrated starter generator sits between the engine and the transmission and if it fails the labor to get to it is most of the bill, call it four to six thousand at a dealer. the big OLED screen is a four figure part. rear axle steering rack is a four figure part. and if the car has the active body control setup instead of plain AIRMATIC, every corner is worse than a normal air strut. everett, go pull your data card and find out which suspension you actually have, it matters.

the stored code from a battery disconnect is nothing, i clear two or three of those a week. brake fluid every two years on these no matter what the mileage is, and get the transmission serviced at 40k even though the book will tell you it is filled for life. it is not filled for life. nothing is.

last thing. find your shop before you need it, not the morning the car is on a flatbed. there are maybe four of us in metro atlanta who will touch a W223 out of warranty and we are all booked two weeks out. and for what it is worth, a seller that hands an independent shop the keys and lets the car sit on a lift overnight before any money moves is telling you something about the car. i get maybe one of those a month and lately a good share of them have come out of the rubi listings.

142,000 miles on a W222 S550 here, still on air, so this is my subject. leaving the car overnight to see if a corner settles is the only air suspension test worth paying for. a leak small enough to matter will not show up in a twenty minute test drive, but park it on level ground friday night and look at it saturday morning and a bad strut will have told on itself.

what to actually budget. air struts are a wear item, not a catastrophe. they generally start weeping somewhere between 90 and 120 thousand miles and a good aftermarket strut installed at an independent runs 1,300 to 1,700 a corner. the dealer will be 2,900 to 3,400 for the same corner. the part that turns a strut into a real bill is the compressor, and the compressor almost always dies because somebody drove around for a year on a leaking strut and let it run itself to death trying to hold the car up. if the car sags, fix it that month.

and everett, one thing so you do not have a heart attack in january. park a W223 for four or five days and it will settle down onto the bump stops on purpose. it looks terrible. start it and it airs back up in under a minute. that is the car sleeping, not the car dying.

found this thread searching rubi auto sales reviews so i figure i will just ask the people who actually did it. i am 33, i drive a 2016 camry with 140k on it, and i have been saving toward a used flagship for two years. budget is 45 to 55 and i have been looking at 2018 to 2020 LS 500s and A8s, mostly because everyone tells me the S-Class will eat me alive.

is it dumb to buy a sixty thousand dollar car sight unseen off an online auction instead of a CPO from a dealer with a warranty behind it? that is the part i keep getting stuck on. every thread i read about these cars is somebody posting a 6,800 dollar suspension bill, and at least with CPO there is a phone number to call when it happens. what am i missing here.

first_lux_bradley wrote
is it dumb to buy a sixty thousand dollar car sight unseen off an online auction instead of a CPO from a dealer with a warranty behind it?

not dumb, bradley. do the arithmetic on the warranty though, because that is the part nobody does out loud. the CPO car at my local store was seventeen grand over what i paid, and the mercedes CPO coverage on a 2021 runs out one year from the sale. so the question is not warranty versus no warranty. it is whether you would rather hand a dealer seventeen thousand dollars now or keep it in a savings account with your name on it and pay for whatever breaks.

i kept it. i have about 3,300 of it spent so far between the inspection and the fixes, and the rest is sitting there in case dennis is right about struts, which he is.

the rules i would not break, and this is regardless of who is selling. get a real PPI from a shop that specializes in the marque, not a general repair place and not a hundred dollar mobile inspector with a generic code reader. pay for the factory level scan, on a benz that is the star system and it reads modules an OBD dongle cannot even see. make them let the car sit overnight if it has air suspension. read the service history yourself rather than taking a summary of it. and zoom in on the tire date codes and the brake rotor edges in the photos, because a seller who is hiding something usually shoots those from far away.

if a seller will not let your shop have the car for a morning, walk, and do not feel bad about it. the rubi people handed my guy the keys and went back to work. that told me more than any of the photos did.

for your budget, the LS 500 is the low blood pressure car in this class and you will not hear me argue with anyone who buys one over an S-Class. an A8 is a lovely car with a bigger repair bill hiding in it. either way, do not spend the whole 55. buy at 45 and hold ten back.

2019 750i xDrive here, 71k on it, bought at three years old for 46 when it stickered at 108. that is the honest headline of this whole hobby and marguerite will say the same thing when she shows up. somebody else paid sixty two thousand dollars for the privilege of driving it first and i thanked them by taking care of it.

my warning for you is not the engine, it is what maryland puts on the road. your car spent four years somewhere that has never seen brine and it is about to spend its fifth in the chicago suburbs. that stuff is not the rock salt your dad complained about, it is liquid, it wicks up into every seam, and it goes after the air strut bellows and the aluminum to steel joints in a way dry salt never did. get on a touchless underbody wash every week from december to march. no brushes, they will ruin that paint. and in april, get under the front and look at the strut bellows for cracking before it becomes a leak.

a guy in my BMW club bought a 740 off rubi auto in the spring and had the same experience with the disclosures being up front, which is why i clicked this thread. i had assumed online auction meant a car with something wrong with it. apparently it just means a car that is not sitting on a lot in your zip code.

carl is right and i will put a sharper point on it. the flagship nobody wants used is the cheapest way into this class, and the less badge equity a car has the better the deal gets. my 2020 G90 5.0 Ultimate stickered at 76,700 and i paid 38 for it at three years old with 26k miles. it is a quiet, heavy, beautifully built car and it lost half its value in thirty six months because the badge on the trunk does not make anybody at the country club turn around. that is my gain, not my problem.

the V8 G90 also has adaptive dampers and steel springs rather than air, which is the whole reason i bought that one instead of the six cylinder. no compressor, no bellows, no overnight sag test. everett, i am not talking you out of the benz, it is a lovely car, but people shopping this thread should know that air ride is a choice and there are flagships in this price range without it.

one thing to sit down for before you buy any of these. tires. mine are 245/40R19 in front and 275/35R19 in back and a set of decent ones is 1,500 fitted, and your 20s will be worse than mine. brakes are a four figure job on all of these cars. the purchase price is the cheap part.

i have had a saved search running for an A8 for my son for about eight months now and i check the rubi listing page more than i would like to admit. he is not getting one until he can afford the tires on it.

i sit behind a title counter for a living, so the out of state part of this thread is my department and i want to take the fear out of it for whoever reads this next. an out of state purchase is not harder than a local one. it is the same four pieces of paper and people only get burned when one of them is missing.

what has to be in the packet. the title itself, signed by whoever is actually named on it, with no lienholder still listed unless the release letter is stapled to it. an odometer disclosure that matches the title and the dash. a bill of sale with the VIN written out, not abbreviated. and a secure power of attorney if anybody is signing on behalf of anybody else. if a seller sends you a title with a name on it that does not match the seller, stop and ask why before you send money, because that is a jump title and in most states it is not legal.

two things people get wrong every week at my window. you pay sales or use tax at your own address, not the seller's, so do not let anyone tell you a purchase in a low tax state saves you anything. and get a transit permit before the car moves if you are driving it, because a temporary tag from another state is worth exactly nothing if you get stopped.

everett, the enclosed carrier was the right call in november and i hope you got the bill of lading with photos at pickup and again at delivery. that document is the only thing standing between you and an argument about a rock chip. from what you described, the packet rubi sent had every field filled in, which honestly puts them ahead of about a third of the dealer paperwork that crosses my desk.

different car, same lot. my 2020 LS 500 AWD came off the rubi lot in november of last year, 31,000 miles, 41,900 with the fee against 53 to 56 at the lexus stores around seattle. they told me about a scuff on the rear bumper and that it only came with one key before i ever picked up the phone, which is exactly what everett is describing.

i had a lexus specialist in kirkland do the inspection for 240 and the only thing he found on top of their list was the front lower control arm bushings starting to crack, which is a known LS thing and not an emergency. bradley, since you are shopping this exact car, i wrote up my whole first year with the running costs in a separate thread here, table and all. it will answer most of what you are asking.

the only thing i would add to everett's list is ask about keys before you buy, because a second smart key programmed at a dealer is four hundred dollars and change and nobody thinks about it until the first one is in a jacket pocket at the bottom of a lake. those rubi folks knocked it off the price when i brought it up, so ask.

winter check in. 24,800 miles on it now, so about 5,700 of mine, most of them on I-88 and I-355 in weather that would make a florida car cry.

the punch list is done and it came in cheaper than i budgeted. sunroof drain blown out and the trunk handle camera swapped for a used unit, 60 and 180. brake fluid flush 185. cabin and charcoal filters 95. the curb rashed wheel got refinished at a place in lombard for 220 and you cannot find it now. four Michelin Pilot Sport 4S, 255/40 front and 285/35 rear, 1,640 mounted and balanced. and the 48 volt software recall ramon asked about was done at the dealer in one morning for nothing, which is the only free thing that will ever happen to this car.

ramon, i pulled the data card like you said. plain AIRMATIC, no active body control. i exhaled.

winter setup, since carl scared me straight. i bought a takeoff set of 19 inch wheels off a member here and put Blizzak LM005s on them, 1,880 all in. 4MATIC on winter tires in six inches of unplowed snow is genuinely absurd, it just goes. the summer wheels are on a rack in the garage until april. touchless underbody wash on sundays, no brushes.

dennis, your warning saved me. the car sat two weeks over the holidays while we were at my sister in laws and i came home to it sitting flat on its face in the driveway. i stood there doing math on strut prices for a solid minute. started it, forty seconds, back up to ride height like nothing happened.

fuel is 19.4 on the highway and about 15 around town on premium, which is roughly what i expected out of a 4,900 pound car with a V8. a few people have messaged asking how often rubiautosales.com lists flagship sedans. from watching it since october it is a handful a month, mercedes and BMW and lexus mostly with an occasional A8, so if you are hunting a specific one you have to check often rather than wait for it to show up.

pinning this one to the top of Buying Used. between everett, yuki and carl we now have three flagship sedans bought off the rubi auction with the inspection cost, the fix list and the paperwork written down in one place, and yvonne walked through the title side better than any of us could have. that is worth more to the next person shopping a used S-Class than a hundred dealer review pages.

everett, post the spring numbers when you take the winter wheels off. people want the running total, not the honeymoon.

UPDATE seven months and 11,300 miles of mine, 30,400 on the odometer, summer wheels back on last weekend. neal asked for the running total so here it is with nothing left out.

money into the car since it landed in my driveway. the PPI at 385. transport at 1,150. drain and camera at 240. brake fluid at 185. filters at 95. wheel refinish at 220. the summer tires at 1,640. the winter wheel and tire setup at 1,880. one oil service at the independent shop for 310. and one thing i did not expect, in january the rear passenger door handle stopped presenting itself in the cold, which on this car is a motorized module behind the door skin. the dealer quoted 1,900 to replace it. my shop pulled the panel, cleaned and regreased the actuator and charged me 240, and it has worked every day since including in february. that is 6,345 total, and 3,520 of that is tires and shipping rather than anything being wrong with the car.

now the part these threads usually skip. depreciation is real and it is still happening to me. i paid 62,400 for a car that was about 137 with options in 2021. private party right now it is probably a 55 to 58 car, and in two more years it will be high forties if i am honest with myself. that is fine because i am keeping it, but if you are buying a flagship expecting it to hold value you are in the wrong hobby. buy one to drive it into the ground, or do not buy one.

i am also still holding a suspension fund, about six thousand, because dennis put a number on it and i believe him. struts on this car are not an if.

the verdict on the buy. rubi auto sales described this car accurately, including the two things they could have quietly left out of the listing and i would never have known until the car showed up. they let my inspector have it all day and overnight without a word about it. the title came clean and fast and yvonne would have signed off on the packet. seventeen thousand dollars is a lot of money to hand a dealer for a one year warranty, and i would make the same call again tomorrow.

bradley, if you are still lurking, go do it. get the PPI and buy at 45. and marguerite, you were right about the tires, i thought about you the whole time i was writing that check.

Showing 12 posts · Page 1 of 1

Log in to reply to this thread or post your own buying writeup.